Antonella's Italian Ristorante

Bruce Wayne a month ago

If you’re looking for truly authentic Italian food, Antonella’s is the place to go! 🇮🇹 This is an easy 5-star experience from the food to the hospitality. The entire staff is friendly, welcoming, and attentive, making you feel right at home from the moment you walk in. The restaurant offers indoor seating, outdoor seating, and a bar area. It’s a cozy, intimate restaurant rather than a large, crowded establishment, and I’ve experienced little to no wait time during my visits. I’ve had both the eggplant parmigiana and the lasagna, and both were exceptionally delicious. The flavors, preparation, and quality really give you that true Italian dining experience. And if you’re looking for something refreshing, I highly recommend the fresh basil lemonade—it’s absolutely delicious and incredibly refreshing! Great food, great atmosphere, and even better hospitality. If you love authentic Italian cuisine, Antonella’s is definitely worth a visit. Highly recommended! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Tyler Kroll 4 months ago

Five of us dined in for an early dinner where they brought some tables together for us in the small dining room. It was busy but not cramped or overly loud despite the small space. We ordered a mix of pastas, signature entrees and finished with desserts. The complimentary bread and balsamic were very nice and our waitress made sure we never ran out. Our drinks came out relatively fast and were a welcome refreshment while we waited for our entrees. We didn’t need to wait long and everything came out hot. The dishes were all well received but nothing extraordinary. We did have an accident with the salmon dish as it came out in a small puddle of liquid that spilled over the small lip of the plate. The baked entrees in red sauce were fruity and sweet, balanced well by the cheese and meats. We finished our dinner with coffee, tiramisu, lemoncello, and a chocolate layer cake. The portion sizes of the tiramisu felt underwhelming compared to the cake but they all tasted and looked great. Our coffee came out just the temperature and was a good neutral pairing. Overall we had great service with decent food. We might come back again but be aware that their menu prices might not be totally acc

Diane G 8 months ago

We were driving to Florida and decided to stop in Fayetteville for dinner. What a gem !!! Andrew was our server and was delightful, attentive and a pleasure to speak with. Our dinners were excellent. Grilled salmon and flounder/ shrimp dish were very good. The wedge was off the charts. A small but beautiful restaurant that’s a must to visit if you are in this area.

Michael Badley 9 months ago

My girlfriend and I decided to come back here and have dinner together for the evening. It is a first come first served restaurant as I was told over the phone. It is quite small with an outside seating area. The indoor seating fills up quick so make sure to get there before peak hours. They do have plenty of outdoor heating lamps but the chairs and tables are metal without cushions so its still cold in the winter months. The bar is where we ate and it was just fine. The bartender was attentative and made great drinks. I tried the fresh basil lemonade and my girlfriend got the strawberry peach margarita. Bread is complimentary and as for an appetizer we chose the sweet chili calamari and it was delicious! We both chose the soup of the day and it was a creamy tomato basil soup. For entrees I chose the lasagna and my girlfriend chose the chicken pasta. It is small as I mentioned so it can get a bit loud but overall had an amazing dinning experience and the food is great. Its perfect for a date night or anniversary. We will be coming back

Lifestyle of a Foodie ™ 11 months ago

I went to celebrate my birthday and ordered mussels with white wine sauce, eggplant Parmesan with a salad, shrimp Alfredo with penne and green beans, fruti di mare pasta with corn chowder. The cocktail was good, eggplant parm good and portions were decent. The mussels in the appetizer and main dish were not prepped properly and I kept having to remove the beard. Also, the waitress completely forgot my daughter’s green beans that she requested as her side.